CCJ President should take the wise step

Aug 15, 2026 Features / Columnists, The GHK Lall Column

Hard Truths by GHK Lall

(Kaieteur News) I think that CCJ President, Dr. Winston Anderson, has only one option. My recommendation is that he tenders. From what is now concretised in the public record, most likely throughout the region, he is radioactive. If the allegations were from one colleague, I would urge him to ride it out.

When it is five, and they wrote what they wrote, matters already gone too far. It is my position. Notwithstanding those of regional judicial heads. Get to the substance, honourable judges. The substance, please.

Thus, I submit, on the interests of the continuity of the CCJ, President Anderson should leave. Regional friends should nudge him. Well-wishers in Guyana, likewise. The region’s apex court is too big, holds too much of a crucial role to be reduced to ongoing scorn.

Here’s his first challenge: who will work with him, look up to him? The second is how does he himself overcome the screamingly raw environment in chambers? I hear the management defense(s) made to two Trinidadian news outlets, but all that is vanquished, past returning. Collegial atmosphere -is somebody kidding? Misunderstanding and mischaracterisation? These are men and women of caliber, deep intellectual powers.

The CCJ is neither plantation nor political hothouse. I have difficulty thinking otherwise when the written communications from different objecting judges all point thereto. There is a problem, and it is a huge one. The allegations are not by word of mouth, heard in passing. They are in writing and loaded. To put differently, he was being called out directly, and sharply. The CCJ has much remedial work ahead. Now for the politics that touched the CCJ.

There’s Guyana’s current Opposition Leader, Mr. Azruddin Mohamed, who fell short of the mark in his matter before the CCJ. Going from the emails alone, it has been a struggle to ascertain how much of a political court the CCJ mutated into, and on whose head outside of the CCJ that rests.

Mr. Mohamed has every right to cry foul. From my perspective, he may have other matters to escalate to the CCJ. But into what minefield would he have entrusted his existence? Mr. Mohamed’s business before the CCJ aside, I would loathe to trust the CCJ when so much hangs in the balance. This is another tragedy that has Guyanese whiffs about it, and hasn’t left the best imprint on Guyanese yearning for justice.

Ask Mr. Mohamed and the people who believe in him. The WIN man has claimed he is being railroaded in Guyana by the ugly politics that prevails here. The issue now faced by Guyanese of all walks (and persuasions) is whether that politics and the alleged railroading reached into the supposedly hallowed sanctum of the CCJ.

From Mr. Azruddin Mohamed, it is to Mr. Aubrey Norton, former Leader of the Opposition. I recall the hiccups and hang ups surrounding the substantive appointments of the chancellor of the judiciary and chief justice of Guyana. For the unfamiliar, these two uppermost positions in the local judiciary have been in a state of suspense for years, unconfirmed, acting holders.

In this snake pit ventured CCJ President Anderson relative to the chancellor (ag). Did he, really? Per Mr. Norton he did, who would have none of it, since it smacked of interference. Score a big one for Mr. Norton. Now, I am trying to make sense of the CCJ president’s action. Surely, a man of his stature and exposure had to know better. How did he end up where he did with the then Opposition Leader of Guyana on the chancellor matter?

Perhaps, it was a good deed. One done on his own initiative and the compulsion of altruism. I wouldn’t hold those against him. But what if it was not? It wouldn’t speak well of President Anderson’s judgment. Nor highly of anyone who gave him that inspiration, which Aubrey Norton rightly found to be grating.

This is my bottom line. President Anderson resigns, and the CCJ is still in a rough place. Should he stay, I wouldn’t think much of the CCJ going forward.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of this newspaper.

Discover more from Kaieteur News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

CCJ President, GHK Lall, hard truths, Mr. Azruddin Mohamed, Opposition Leader

Latest News