Latest update November 19th, 2026 10:20 AM
May 11, 2018 News
Trinidad -The Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) yesterday resolved a family dispute involving lands in Essequibo, Guyana.
In 2002, Mr. Kowsal Narine filed a claim against his brother, Mr. Deonarine Natram, claiming that their father, Mr. Nateram, had been in possession of the lands since 1959 and had therefore acquired prescriptive title to the lands.
Mr. Kowsal Narine also claimed that he had acquired prescriptive title to the lands.
The CCJ allowed the appeal and declared that Mr. Kowsal Narine had been in sole and undisturbed possession of the land since 1 June 1991 and that any title, right or interest of Mr. Deonarine Natram had been extinguished.
In 1959, Mr. Nateram entered into an agreement to purchase the lands from Mr. Ashbourne Chan and Mr. Foster Chan, who were also named as defendants.
Payments were made to the Chans but Mr. Nateram never paid the full purchase price although the Chans permitted him to take possession of the lands. The last payment was made to the Chans by Mr. Nateram in August 1965.
In 1989, Mr Nateram signed an agreement by which he gifted the land to Mr. Deonarine
Natram. Mr. Deonarine Natram then approached the Chans and they agreed to sell the land to
him for $9,950 on the same day, but transport was not passed to him by the Chans until the year
2002.
Mr. Deonarine Natram instituted a claim against Mr. Kowsal Narine and another brother, Mr. Narine Nateram, in which he sought damages and an injunction restraining them from using the land. He also asked for an order that they yield possession of the land to him. This claim was discontinued in March 1990.
In May 1990, Mr Nateram made a will giving the lands to Mr. Kowsal Narine. Mr Nateram died on 31 May 1991.
The dispute between the brothers intensified in 2002 when Mr. Deonarine Natram came on the lands and burned some seed paddy. Mr. Kowsal Narine took the matter to the High Court in Guyana.
At the trial before Justice Roxanne George, Mr. Kowsal Narine, gave evidence that he had assisted his father with the cultivation of the lands from 1973 until 1981, when his father gave him exclusive possession of the lands. He also testified that he paid $75.00 per acre as rent to his father until the latter’s death.
His evidence was that he remained in exclusive possession of the lands after his father’s death. The trial judge found that the father had acquired prescriptive title to the lands in 1978 on the basis that he had become a tenant at will one year after the last payment was made in 1965, that is, in 1966.
She also found that Mr. Kowsal Narine had acquired prescriptive title in his own right.
Mr. Deonarine Natram appealed the decision of the trial judge. The Court of Appeal found that the father was not a tenant at will but rather a licensee. The court also disagreed with the trial judge’s finding that Mr. Kowsal Narine had acquired prescriptive title in his own right. The appeal was allowed and costs awarded to Mr. Deonarine Natram in the sum of $100,000.
Mr. Kowsal Narine appealed to the CCJ. The CCJ agreed with Guyana’s Court of Appeal that the father was not a tenant at will, but a licensee, having entered into possession of the lands in 1959 with the consent of the Chans.
That licence was not terminated by the Chans and Nateram never paid the full purchase price. The CCJ analyzed the status of a purchaser who had not paid the full purchase price but who was put into possession of land by the vendor/landowner in Guyana.
The CCJ accepted that on the father’s death the licence granted by the Chans to Mr.Nateram automatically terminated and the nature of the possession changed.
Mr. Kowsal Narine thereafter remained in possession of the lands from 1 June 1991 in his own right.
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Nov 19, 2026
…16-year-old S/A U18 record-holder becomes third Guyanese athletics talent to secure partnership By Rawle Toney (Kaieteur News) – Sixteen-year-old Guyanese middle-distance sensation Olivia...Nov 19, 2026
(Kaieteur News) – There is something particularly obscene about welcoming the labour of desperate people, making use of their willingness to work, and then permitting landlords to turn the migrant’s desperation into exploitative business. Guyana, in its headlong rush to prosperity, appears to...Nov 01, 2026
By Sir Ronald Sanders (Kaieteur News) – When Commonwealth leaders gather in Antigua and Barbuda from 1st to 4th November, they should address a question that reaches beyond their association: how can countries of different size, wealth and outlook sustain cooperation in a world increasingly...Nov 19, 2026
(Kaieteur News) – Let’s do the math. The issue is the now deferred ex-presidents’ benefits bill. The bill is so disparaged, so denounced, that its official name is spat upon. The math says that three of the four ex-presidents are older than I am. One is over 80 years old; two are...Freedom of speech is our core value at Kaieteur News. If the letter/e-mail you sent was not published, and you believe that its contents were not libellous, let us know, please contact us by phone or email.
Feel free to send us your comments and/or criticisms.
Contact: 624-6456; 225-8452; 225-8458; 225-8463; 225-8465; 225-8473 or 225-8491.
Or by Email: glennlall2000@gmail.com / kaieteurnews@yahoo.com