Latest update November 20th, 2026 10:25 AM
Nov 19, 2026 News
(Kaieteur News) – High Court judge, Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif on Wednesday dismissed a judicial review challenge filed on behalf of Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed, upholding a Magistrate’s decision to deny him bail and keeping him remanded at Lusignan Prison on a Cybercrime charge.
Delivering her written judgment following Tuesday’s substantive hearing, Justice Chandra-Hanif rejected the Fixed Date Application filed by Mohamed’s mother, Bonita Mohamed, which sought to quash Sparendaam Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’s October 30, 2026 bail refusal. In the decision, the judge stated, “Accordingly, this court dismisses this Fixed Date Application filed on 2nd November, 2026 for an order of certiorari to quash the decision of the first respondent dated 30th October, 2026 refusing to admit Azruddin Mohamed to bail.”
The High Court concluded that the legal arguments mounted against the magistrate’s ruling fell short of the threshold required for judicial intervention. Justice Chandra-Hanif ruled, “further based on the detailed and careful judgment above, the court finds that the applicant has failed to establish all of the judicial review grounds alleged entitling them to the relief claimed.”
In her analysis of the substantive issues, Justice Chandra-Hanif noted that the law does not ordinarily oblige a court to wait for another offence to be committed before recognising a sufficiently evidenced risk of one, while cautioning in the same breath that the mere existence of an accusation must not be converted into proof of a propensity to offend. She found that the prosecution went beyond the bare fact of other pending charges and pointed to a discernible connection across matters, including allegations of obstructing justice and interfering with witnesses, and added that where grounded information points to a real risk of witness interference, a magistrate may give that concern substantial weight even at a preliminary stage without requiring proof beyond reasonable doubt.
Addressing how the different proceedings were raised below, Justice Chandra-Hanif observed that those matters were not introduced solely by the prosecution to prejudice the applicant. She stated, “In doing so, the defence itself invited the learned Magistrate to consider the relationship between the various criminal proceedings and the significance of events occurring in those proceedings to the charge then before her,” explaining that having invited the magistrate to examine that relationship to argue the alleged weakness of the cybercrime case, the opposition leader could not reasonably maintain that she was barred from considering those same circumstances when evaluating the prosecution’s submissions.
Defence counsel, Roysdale Forde had argued that seriousness was treated as a ground for refusal on an offence not classified as serious under the act, which carries liability on conviction on indictment to a fine of GYD$8 million and five years’ imprisonment, that a likelihood of offending was stated as a “view” without evidence and inverted the inference from other grants of bail where no breach was established, and that Magistrate Gibbs failed to weigh required statutory considerations, consider conditions, or give sufficient reasons.
Attorney General and Minister of People’s Affairs Anil Nandlall, adopting submissions by King’s Counsel Darshan Ramdhani for the Director of Public Prosecutions, argued that the court’s role was limited to checking for illegality, irrationality, or procedural impropriety rather than substituting a different view.
Clarifying the scope of the review, Justice Chandra-Hanif ruled that developments after the October 30 ruling could not be used to fault the magistrate’s original determination. Her judgment noted, “Any factors not considered by the court in its judgment are deemed to be irrelevant to the application before the court for judicial review of decision dated 30th October, 2026 as any issue arising after cannot reasonably have been taken into account by the magistrate to inform her decision,” though she also noted that Mohamed remains entitled to renew a bail application before the magistrate at any stage if disclosure or later developments show the feared risk is unfounded, diminished, or manageable.
In arriving at her conclusion, Justice Chandra-Hanif highlighted the restraint reviewing courts must exercise when examining lower court rulings, citing precedent from Lord Hoffmann, who expressly recognised that “reasons for judgment will always be capable of having been better expressed.” The ruling reiterated that a reviewing court “should not substitute their own discretion for that of the judge by a narrow textual analysis which enables them to claim that he misdirected himself.”
Before concluding, the High Court addressed the intense public scrutiny and political commentary surrounding the high-profile matter, firmly asserting its independence from outside debate.
“Finally, this court considers it necessary to emphasise that, although these proceedings, by reason of the identity of the parties involved and the considerable public attention they have attracted, have regrettably transcended the confines of the courtroom and become the subject of intense political debate and controversy, this [Court has] neither participated in, nor been influenced by, the political discourse,” the judge stated, adding that the court has “remained steadfastly guided by its” legal principles.
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Nov 20, 2026
(Kaieteur News) – The Guyana Defence Force (GDF) Women’s Football Club met a fierce challenge from Ann’s Grove United FC on Wednesday night when the Guyana Football Federation’s (GFF)...Nov 20, 2026
(Kaieteur News) – Horse racing in Guyana has always been an exciting and popular sport. The horses run, the jockeys ride, the punters gamble and the owners hope. But there is one thing that seems to be moving at a considerably slower pace than everything else: regulation. Guyana finally got...Nov 01, 2026
By Sir Ronald Sanders (Kaieteur News) – When Commonwealth leaders gather in Antigua and Barbuda from 1st to 4th November, they should address a question that reaches beyond their association: how can countries of different size, wealth and outlook sustain cooperation in a world increasingly...Nov 20, 2026
(Kaieteur News) – I always thought that Senior Supt. Prem Narine was specially gifted. If nothing else, he has special friends. Just a few short years ago, Mr. Narine was a Guyana Police unknown. A regular copper. Did he soar into the stratosphere! Jumping from junior past Inspector,...Freedom of speech is our core value at Kaieteur News. If the letter/e-mail you sent was not published, and you believe that its contents were not libellous, let us know, please contact us by phone or email.
Feel free to send us your comments and/or criticisms.
Contact: 624-6456; 225-8452; 225-8458; 225-8463; 225-8465; 225-8473 or 225-8491.
Or by Email: glennlall2000@gmail.com / kaieteurnews@yahoo.com