Latest update November 17th, 2026 10:25 AM
(Kaieteur News) – President Irfaan Ali has a lot of explaining to do. He may think that he is, but he is not above the people. He is the head-of-state, elected to that role by citizens. He is answerable to them. Why was the Chairman of the MV Barima Commission of Inquiry, Justice Godfrey Smith’s resignation not accepted? Accepted with a heavy heart, but accepted nonetheless.
President Ali owes it to every citizen to share what makes the presence of Justice Smith on the MV Barima COI so indispensable that he cannot be parted with, that he has to stay. We at this paper commend the former Belizean Foreign Minister and jurist also for taking the fine step of offering his resignation. Guyana’s president had only one response left to him: accept that resignation and wish Justice Smith the best of health and the same in his future endeavours.
In appointing the COI, President Ali had said that the terms of reference will include “establishing the full circumstances surrounding the tragedy…” Any practical definition of “full circumstances” would point a finger at no less a figure than the president himself. When he kept holding on to members of his Cabinet who had developed a long record of failure on many matters, including MV Barima projects, the full circumstances honestly and comprehensively applied must include the president. By retaining those Cabinet members, he placed long reins in their hands, the result of which was unparalleled failure, and a tragedy to match. A new boat not used as a replacement for an ailing MV Barima was one failure that led to massive human consequences. A wharf that was not completed, and could not be commissioned into action, was another costly error that contributed in a huge way to the MV Barima still plying the seas, and causing the death of 79 citizens.
A no holds barred, hard driving, take no prisoners MV Barima COI chair should have little difficulty piecing the facts together, and making the connections that spare none in the PPPC Government. It is apparent that President Ali’s so-called ‘emphatic’ rejection of Chairman Smith’s offer to resign is built more on politics than on any search for the full facts leading to what has been called Guyana’s worst maritime disaster. We think that with the exception of the Rev Jim Jones’ holocaust, the MV Barima capsizing, and its attendant death toll, is Guyana’s worst ever disaster by any measurement. Citizens should not forget that the Jim Jones’ massacre was of foreign origins and its victims were almost all foreign.
A national tragedy of the MV Barima proportions, therefore, should be led by the cleanest of the clean, one unfettered by any handicap. Justice Smith may have his sound defences, and much going for him, but that US visa revocation left a shadow that is not going away, because it follows his every step, his actions. We do not think that this is a positive for the Barima COI. We do not think that this is fair to the families, who have already had much to complain about. They have to rest assured that they are getting the most penetrating COI that is possible, one that pulls no punches, one that does not shrink from the challenges in front of it. And, a COI whose members do not feel obligated in any way to anyone in Guyana, most of all the government.
It is proper that another statement from President Ali is put before the citizens of Guyana. He had said that the COI is tasked to “evaluate…whether any acts of negligence, misconduct, dereliction of duty, or other failures by any individual, entity, institution contributed to, or caused the disaster.” Any basic evaluation is sure to unearth much of what the president outlined. But, by the law of unintended consequences this broad mandate has to encompass most, if not all, of the PPPC Government. There are neither any innocents in this tragedy, save for the dead and the mourning, nor should there be any sacred cows that are untouchable. The MV Barima was a manmade tragedy, a failure of governance and leadership. In refusing to accept the resignation, what is the endgame?
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Nov 17, 2026
…Guyana humble Puerto Rico 4 – 2 to return to League A By Rawle Toney (Kaieteur News) – The Golden Jaguars produced a memorable second-half comeback to defeat Puerto Rico 4-2 at the National...Nov 17, 2026
(Kaieteur News) – There are many things that make Guyana unique. We have the world’s largest single-drop waterfall, one of the most magnificent rainforests on the planet, an oil industry that promises to make us all prosperous, and, apparently, a public service in which employees have come...Nov 01, 2026
By Sir Ronald Sanders (Kaieteur News) – When Commonwealth leaders gather in Antigua and Barbuda from 1st to 4th November, they should address a question that reaches beyond their association: how can countries of different size, wealth and outlook sustain cooperation in a world increasingly...Nov 17, 2026
(Kaieteur News) – It’s one of the mysteries of Guyana that I labor to appreciate, to unravel. The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP Office). It’s a miracle by itself when the DPP Office commands muscle and mind to combine to set matters straight. It could also be the...Freedom of speech is our core value at Kaieteur News. If the letter/e-mail you sent was not published, and you believe that its contents were not libellous, let us know, please contact us by phone or email.
Feel free to send us your comments and/or criticisms.
Contact: 624-6456; 225-8452; 225-8458; 225-8463; 225-8465; 225-8473 or 225-8491.
Or by Email: glennlall2000@gmail.com / kaieteurnews@yahoo.com