We must acknowledge the gap between legal rights and lived realities

Jun 12, 2025 Letters

---

Dear Editor,

Kaieteur News – In May, Guyana marked the 30th anniversary of the Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTOP) Act of 1995. As we reflect on this milestone, we consider both the significance of this landmark legislation and the continued struggle for reproductive justice in our country. This law, passed on May 4, 1995, established Guyana as a regional leader in reproductive rights, making it one of only two countries in the Caribbean where abortion is legally available on request in early pregnancy.

The MTOP Act remains remarkably progressive even by today’s standards. It legalises abortion on request up to 8 weeks, provides broader access between 8-12 weeks with a single medical practitioner’s approval, and includes provisions for later abortions with additional medical consultation. Crucially, it acknowledges various grounds for access, including physical and mental health risks, fetal abnormalities, rape, incest, HIV status, and contraceptive failure. The legislation explicitly respects patient confidentiality and autonomy, requiring neither partner nor parental notification. Additionally, the law also allows mid-level health professionals such as medexes, midwives, nurses, pharmacists, and other appropriately trained and registered persons to lawfully provide nonsurgical abortions in early pregnancy under the supervision of a medical practitioner. 

At its core, the Act recognised what remains true today: access to safe, legal abortion is essential for women’s health, autonomy, and full participation in society. The legislation aimed “to enhance the dignity and sanctity of life by reducing the incidence of induced abortion” and “to enhance the attainment of safe motherhood by eliminating deaths and complications due to unsafe abortion.” Three decades later, these remain worthy objectives.

Yet as we commemorate this milestone, we must acknowledge the gap between legal rights and lived realities. Despite its progressive framework, barriers limiting access to abortion services still exist for far too many women and girls in Guyana. Limited public awareness about the Act means that many people are still largely unaware of their legal rights. This lack of awareness also includes healthcare providers; problematically, many of them are also ignorant of the law.

The Ministry of Health has systematically failed to ensure that safe abortion-trained staff are consistently available at all public hospitals across Guyana’s regions. This reinforces inequity and effectively puts safe abortion care out of the reach for many women in hinterland communities, who are still forced to travel significant distances to access such care.  This represents a direct failure of the state’s obligation to provide equitable healthcare access to all citizens, thirty years after establishing this legal right.

Economic factors compound these institutional failures, as many women cannot afford services at private facilities and may feel reluctant to seek services at public institutions due to concerns about confidentiality or perceived stigma. The perpetuation of stigma around abortion is further reinforced by religious leaders and institutions that promote shame and judgment. Their messaging directly contradicts the progressive framework of the MTOP and actively undermines women seeking constitutionally protected healthcare.

As we look toward the next decade of reproductive rights in Guyana, meaningful progress demands immediate accountability from those responsible for implementation failures. The Ministry of Health must ensure trained providers are available in every region and mandate comprehensive education for all healthcare workers about their legal obligations under the MTOP Act. Public education about the Act and service availability remains essential. Community conversations about reproductive health must create space for open, non-judgmental dialogue that respects women’s autonomy and decisions.

Looking across the Caribbean, where many countries still criminalise abortion even to save a woman’s life, Guyana’s MTOP Act stands as a beacon of progressive legislation. But progressive laws mean nothing without progressive implementation.  Our collective work now demands that we hold accountable those institutions and individuals who have failed to uphold the promises made thirty years ago.

On the 30th anniversary, we honour those who fought for the passage of the MTOP Act and recommit ourselves to the ongoing work of ensuring its promises are realised for all women, regardless of location, economic status, or background. The right to reproductive healthcare is not a privilege for the few but a fundamental right for all, and it’s past time our institutions treated it as such.

In solidarity,

Akola Thompson

Akeisha Cave

Sandi Bowen

---

• Akeisha Cave, Akola Thompson, Legal rights, Sandi Bowen

---