Mocha Arcadia: bulldozing of homes a human rights violation

Jan 08, 2023 Letters

Dear Editor,

The Working People’s Alliance condemns in the strongest terms the recent Government action against homeowners in Mocha Arcadia. Whatever the state of negotiations, if there were any, between the two sides, some other outcome short of demolition of the houses should have ensued.

Bulldozing people’s homes against their will is a human rights violation, but worse, it is an act that reeks of disdain, and disrespect for citizens who have not offended the law or the government. The images broadcasted to the world from that village brings back memories of South Africa’s apartheid era and justifies the charges by sections of the African Guyanese community that Guyana is an emerging Apartheid State.

The issue here cannot be resistance to ‘development’, as the Government seeks to cast it. WPA wishes to make it abundantly clear that it is strongly opposed to any development at the expense of the dignity and rights of people. It is patently clear that the land in question is not an obstruction to the proposed new roadway.

So, why has the Government been so determined to evict the occupants at all costs? The answer obviously has to do with Government’s acquisition of the land because of its potential value. WPA thinks this is naked land-grabbing on the part of a Government which has already been accused of transferring State and Ancestral Lands to its friends and cronies.

It should be noted that this is the second demolition act by the Government in the last year—the previous one being in Linden. These actions are in stark contrast to the issuing of titles to “squatters” in communities deemed to be supportive of the government.

The Government cannot not know that the perception and reality of unequal treatment undermine its own stated mantra of ‘One Guyana’. Further, the option of forced removal of mainly people of African descent whether it is in Linden, Mocha Arcadia or Georgetown where the stalls of vendors were recently demolished against their will, represent acts of brutality and terror that have no place in modern society.

The events in Mocha Arcadia, therefore, open the Government to charges of racial profiling and racial discrimination in the process of governance. This, in the International Decade of the People of African Descent, an UN-sanctioned observation, to which the Guyana Government is a signatory.

The withholding of funds from the local body, IDPADA-G coupled with the wanton demolition of African Guyanese homes and business places point to a deliberateness of action on the part of the government. WPA warns that these actions are pregnant with ethno-political provocation which threatens the wholeness of our country.

WPA is also incensed by the cynical act of demolishing people’s homes and immediately after calling them with offers of money and alternative homes. Such cynicism is akin to willfully killing people and offering to pay for their burial. In any case, the arrogance of unilaterally deciding the worth of compensation is manifestation of the inhuman attitude of the government on this and similar issues.

That inhumanity was on full display by some of the police officers who accompanied the demolition force from the Ministry of Housing. The brutalization of the women by at least one officer and their subsequent arrests are astonishing. WPA calls for the charging and prosecution of the officer or officers in question. Nothing less should suffice.

Finally, the WPA is also astonished by and roundly berates the President for his cowardly justification of the actions taken at Mocha.

The Head of State and Government boldly justified the debacle as a form of “strength.” He made clear that he did not want to appear weak. It is now abundantly clear that Guyana is governed by a government whose praxis is driven by force and is normalizing such force.

WPA warns that indiscriminate Government force leads to fear, fear leads to desperation, and desperation leads to instability.

Working People’s Alliance