Latest update January 8th, 2025 12:02 AM
Latest News
The no-confidence vote is final
Dear Editor,
It is quite ironic that over the past years, at least after the 2011 General Elections, a parliamentary majority has always been defined by a vote of 33:32, but not unexpectedly but quite Quixotic, the recent support of the no-confidence motion by a vote of 33:32 is not seen as a majority by the losers of the ‘good life’.
The ‘good life’ posse is now in denial. According to lawyer cum mathematician, Nigel Hughes, a majority vote in Guyana’s parliament of 65 members is now deemed to be 34 and not 33. The number of members as determined by the National Assembly is 65.
This learned legal luminary should know that the reason why there are 65 members in the National Assembly rather than 66 is because of the need to avoid a tie and so frustrate the functions of this supreme lawmaking body of the land.
This is no accident and certainly not co-incidental and Hughes’ vast knowledge of constitutional laws and its interpretation should afford him an accurate analysis and interpretation of Article 106 (6) which unambiguously states that, ‘The Cabinet including the President shall resign if the Government is defeated by the vote of a majority of ALL elected members of the National Assembly’.
The ‘elected members’ totaled 65 and a majority is 33. When the Opposition, on 15th August, 2014 tabled a ‘no-confidence’ brought about by Nagamootoo against the PPP/C Government the majority would have been deemed to be 33 if Parliament was not prorogued by then President Donald Ramotar. No one at the time had argued that if the ‘no-confidence’ was put to the vote that 34 votes would have been needed.
Therefore, the pertinent question is: Has this ‘majority’ changed on 21st December 2018? Furthermore, all the Budget cuts after 2011 General Elections should have to now be deemed illegal, the passing of the Budgets after 2015 should all be deemed illegal since all were voted with a majority of 33:32.
The Constitution is not about rounding of figures since a member cannot be halved and subjected to the rounding off. The vote of 33:32 is a clear majority and many organizations recognize this fact, hence the reason for electing odd numbers so as not to stymie and obstruct the fulfilment of the functions of such organizations where voting on decisions are inevitable and vital.
Some questions need to be answered: What would have been the case if the Government side obtained 33 votes? Would Nigel Hughes have said that they needed 34? Or would the ‘no-confidence’ motion be struck down by the Speaker?
Of course the ‘no-confidence’ motion would have been defeated! All the members on the Government side knew this and commanded their members to the point of threatening them that they should vote ‘no’! The high drama, the liberal use of expletives by the Government MPs, the uncouth and unprofessional behaviour of some who supported this. They knew that the 33:32 is all that is needed, but now is time to deny that the false confidence of ‘bring it on’ has now resulted in no confidence.
It is heartening to see that the Guyana Bar Association has condemned and totally rejected the ‘unofficial calculation of the no-confidence’ and has called for elections by March. The Association ‘urged Guyanese to ignore Attorney-at-law Nigel Hughes’ calculation that 34 of the 65 votes in the National Assembly are needed’ to pass that Motion.
I do believe that Mr Hughes should have been more circumspect about his premature public utterance. The no-confidence vote is final!
The Leader of the Opposition, Dr Bharrat Jagdeo has led his people out of PNC bondage in just three and a half years. Guyanese are now in sight of the ‘good life’ in 2019 and should not allow traitors like those in the AFC to snatch this away from them!
Yours sincerely,
Haseef Yusuf
RDC Councilor-Region 6
Similar Articles
THE BLUNT OF THE DAY
Sports
Features/Columnists
Boxing should be banned
Peeping Tom… Kaieteur News- Olympic boxing now finds itself as at a crossroads. A recent report in the Kaieteur News... more
Forget Begging Rich Nations: Caribbean Countries Should Act to Save Themselves
By Sir Ronald Sanders Kaieteur News- It has long been evident that the world’s richest nations, especially those responsible... more
Weekend Cartoon
