His comments are disrespectful to the Auditor-General

Oct 20, 2016 Letters

---

Dear Editor;
Let me first indicate that I shall not attempt any of those reckless generalisations about the purpose and intent of the Contingency Funds which have now been popularised by a very misinformed Minister of Finance, Mr. Winston Jordan. As he unshackles his comments from the more measured versions the nation was accustomed to, under Mr. Carl Greenidge (the last PNC Minister of Finance), Jordan continues to put the PNC chances of winning the 2020 elections at great risk. His open acts of incompetence continue to actively contribute to the mal-administration of the economy. But on top of such incompetence, we are now seeing public acts of intimidation against anyone who questions his strategically bankrupt public actions. The latest victim is the Office of the Auditor General.
His comments which smack of darker antipathies against the functionalities of the Office of the Auditor General, did not escape my notice. If we are to follow his logic, then the innocent taxpayers who are toiling to fill the Treasury are at the mercy of the GREAT MINISTER who claims he has sole rights to do what he wants with the people’s money because of a clause in Section 41 of the Fiscal Management and Accountability Act, Act 20 of 2003 (FMA). But what the Minister is not telling the people is that those “sole rights” are not automatically bequeathed to him by some monarchical edicts, unless all of a sudden we have a King in Guyana since May 2015. Those rights have to be earned after following due process.
The Office of the Auditor General quite correctly pointed out that the Minister has not followed due process on the expenditure totalling a hefty sum of G$604 million and thus he violated the spirit and intent of the law. But only a financial inept person and an impetuous pugilist will not recognise such violations.
That same FMA clearly establishes the criteria for tapping the Contingency Funds and it is as basic as this – the expenses charged to the Contingency Funds must be urgent, unavoidable and unforeseen and only if injury to the public interest is a direct consequence, can we proceed to make those expenses. But all four criteria must be met. On G$604 million in expenses, the Minister has failed to meet all four criteria.
The Minister has violated the spirit of the law and the Office of the Auditor General is correct to write him up. The Minister’s action in 2015 (which continues in 2016), is nothing but reckless financial abuse. Therefore, this act of bullying the Auditor General is uncalled for and by right President Granger has to step in, unless he uninterested in arresting these open acts of public bullying.
At all times the Government of Guyana must be seen to be giving all Constitutional Offices, the necessary latitude to do their job. I am calling upon the British diplomats, who have a history of good governance, in particular to pay keen attention to what is going on in Guyana. The members of staff at the Audit Office are trained people who have the collective skill-set to make informed declarations in a national report. They have a job to do, so why are they not being allowed to do their jobs?
The Minister has no right to abrogate due process. Therefore, there is no need for such ignorance from the Minister because he lacks training in the science of financial accountability. Whatever was published in the 2015 Auditor General Report was put there after consulting the Accountant General and other technicians in the Ministry of Finance. Therefore this was a collaborative and collective effort; not a personal attack on the Minister.
Rather the Minister will do very well to focus on his job and save the Guyanese economy from “flat-lining”. But it is clear he has time for everything else but doing his job. This is a clear case of this Minister drawing salary under questionable circumstances since every day that goes by, exposes the fact that the solution to Guyana’s economic problems is beyond the competence of this Minister.
I have reviewed the period under Jordan stewardship in Main Street and I cannot find one progressive policy that will directly create new jobs, new economic growth and will aid in the economic transformation of Guyana. So after 25% of the term has evaporated, his record of performance makes him one of the worst performers in Main Street; if not the worst.
Because with such a parlous performance from Jordan, I would not be shocked if even his ardent supporters in the PNC will, today, not pay even half of a penny for him and his dictatorial attitudes. Jordan’s actions today will cost President Granger dearly in 2020.
We might not have to wait on 2020, since this tragic performance of Jordan has already started to infect the output from the Minister of the Presidency and the Office of President Granger directly. President Granger has to bite the bullet and do the right thing and appoint the best finance brain in his cabinet to the post – Carl Barrington Greenidge.
I humbly submit to His Excellency the President and his top advisor the Senior Minister of State Mr. Joseph Harmon this suggestion; it is time to bury the hatchet with Greenidge and better utilise his competence, experience and skill to turn around the economy. Keeping him out of Main Street continues to do great damage to the nation.
Hoyte trusted Greenidge with the biggest project of that decade – turning around the economy and he successfully did it. It was under Greenidge that Guyana moved from negative 5% growth rate in 1989 to positive 8% by the time he delivered the Office of the Minister of Finance to Dr. Asgar Ally (PPP). I am convinced Carl Barrington Greenidge can do it again. It is time for the real talent in the PNC to be given a chance to showcase that party and it is time for the “kwaks” to be given their marching orders.
The resources in the Treasury do not belong to Mama Jordan or Papa Jordan, they belong to the people of Guyana and these acts of continued financial abuse and disrespect for the spirit and intent of the laws that governs financial accountability in the land is indefensible and must be rejected today, tomorrow and in 2020.
Jai (Harry) Lal

---

---