The Indian diplomatic debacle

Mar 16, 2014 Editorial

The dismissal of visa fraud charges against India’s former Deputy Consul-General in New York, Devyani Khobragade, does not mean that she has been fully absolved of wrongdoing, but it does provide an opportunity for India and the United States to pursue the path of normalisation in their bilateral relations.
The New York District Court did not go into the merits of the charges against her, but decided the matter on the technical ground that she enjoyed diplomatic immunity after she was accredited to India’s Permanent Mission to the United Nations.
This immunity was acquired during the pendency of criminal proceedings for allegedly giving false information to procure a visa for her housekeeper. The diplomatic immunity was a status that India cloaked her with to avoid a felony trial. India’s refusal to waive her immunity led to the host country asking her to leave.
A fresh indictment, however, is still possible. This means that Ms. Khobragade will never be able to return to the U.S., unless she is prepared to face fresh prosecution. India’s guarded reaction — welcoming the outcome but noting that the verdict is silent on the merits of the case as well as the legality of her unseemly arrest and intrusive body search — indicates that it expects a little more from the United States.
By saying “the government hopes to see further progress in this matter in a manner consistent with international norms and conventions,” India is seeking a permanent closure of the case. A remark by a State Department spokesman that the U.S. administration is “surprised” by the court ruling is intriguing, as it knew all along that diplomatic immunity created a jurisdictional bar on her prosecution.
The road ahead for both the countries lies in putting behind the frostiness created by the episode and restoring their high-level engagement. Both countries understand the need to restore trust and moderation in bilateral relations.
The dismissal of her indictment paves the way for this, but there are issues that remain to be addressed. India has to strengthen the principle of reciprocity in dealings with other nations. It needs to devise a code of conduct under which its officials posted abroad will not violate domestic laws.
It needs a policy on consular and diplomatic officials engaging domestic workers so that there is no room for suspicion of human trafficking. On a wider canvas, the country needs legislation to protect domestic workers from under-payment and exploitation.
The U.S., on the other hand, will have to introspect on its overall approach: its failure to anticipate the fallout of the arrest, the manner of the arrest and its controversial decision to “evacuate” the family of the maid at the centre of the storm in an obviously pre-emptive move.
It is amazing that one never heard of such a conflict with any other country but then again, no other country suffered as the United States did on September 11, 2001. This has led to the establishment of what is now known as the Department of Homeland Security.
There is more than meets the eye here. The maid recruited by the Deputy Consul-General certainly did not travel with the woman. She was therefore recruited by the Deputy Consul General. Had she travelled with the Deputy Consul General then she would have had to be in possession of a visa to enter the country.
This maid was therefore recruited in New York and she must have been there on a holiday visa and needed another to cover her new status. But then again, this woman had been working for a while. She felt that she was underpaid and made to live under slave-like conditions.
Whatever the case, this was a case that has effectively ended the diplomatic career of an Indian woman. Anywhere she goes she would be seen as the diplomat caught up in a visa problem over a maid.

Latest News

The Indian diplomatic debacle

Related

Similar Articles

The Glenn Lall Show | December, 2nd, 2024

Follow on Tik Tok @Glennlall

THE BLUNT OF THE DAY

Sports

Thomas’ hat-trick inspires D.C Caesar Fox 10-5 victory, as Annai...

Stabroek Ballers, Sparta Boss, Bent Street...

West Indies Falter in Disheartening Series Loss...

Trophy Stall hands over trophies for Kennard...

Omari Glasgow, carrying the hopes and dreams of a...

GCF eyeing growth across other regions in 2025...

Features/Columnists

The stakes are high in Guyana’s democracy

Let the asylum seekers go: a first step for Venezuela to rebuild relations in the Americas

A leader undresses in public

Publisher’s Note

Weekend Cartoon

Bridge Watch

Demerara Harbour Bridge

> Berbice Bridge […]

The Indian diplomatic debacle

Share this:

Related

Similar Articles

The Glenn Lall Show | December, 2nd, 2024

Follow on Tik Tok @Glennlall

THE BLUNT OF THE DAY

Sports

Features/Columnists

Publisher’s Note

Weekend Cartoon

Bridge Watch

Demerara Harbour Bridge

> Berbice Bridge […]