Magistrate’s weak stance on domestic violence case disappoints

Apr 19, 2011 Letters

Dear Editor,
It was with horror that I read the news report of the April 12th, 2011 court proceedings in New Amsterdam. On this day, Magistrate Adela Nagamootoo sentenced Charles Goodluck – who abused, stalked and stabbed his former lover in the face after she ended their relationship – to one year in prison. One single year! For attempted murder! [Or felonious wounding, as the charge in this case was somehow reduced to…]
The news report states that Mr. Goodluck had previously been charged with murder, manslaughter, attempted murder, and assault and wounding – all committed on former female partners of his.
Surely Magistrate Nagamootoo knew about this man’s record when she was considering his sentence (the newspaper did; so should she). I cannot understand then, how she could possibly have decided that one year in jail was sufficient punishment for the crime of what still appears to me, to be attempted murder. His multiple victims, having experienced enormous fear, pain, and suffering for numerous years, surely deserve better justice than this weak brand dispensed by Magistrate Nagamootoo.
Further confusing the situation is the fact that Magistrate Nagamootoo had previously appeared to be an ally of the victims of domestic violence – doling out deservedly stern sentences to wife beaters, rapists, and other perpetrators of crime and violence in the past 17 months since her swearing in. However, her soft sentencing in the case of Mr. Goodluck now casts a shadow on her previously commendable stance.
Such weak sentencing is frustrating and demoralizing to the victims and survivors of domestic violence, for it sends the message that the court system in Guyana does not take their pain and suffering seriously and will not help to keep their abusers from hurting them further.
The Goodluck case is a clear example of that – here is a man who abused and terrorized women for years, yet was allowed to walk free time and time again, to continue hurting woman after woman. Some may say that he has had tremendous ‘good luck’ indeed; his victims on the other hand, cannot boast of the same good fortune.
This is not an isolated incident however – just last week Red Thread and Grassroots Women Across Race highlighted another case – that of Vanessa Francis who was stabbed 10 times by her former partner. Even though her attacker was caught and taken before the court (on another, different assault charge), he was freed and continues to stalk and threaten her.
Vanessa Francis now lives each day in fear – all because the police and judicial system in Guyana are not working properly.
The blatant disregard for women’s lives and safety that these cases illustrate reveal a deep sickness that is festering within Guyana. We are mired in a very toxic society that creates and encourages men like Mr. Goodluck, and we all need to do everything we can within our power to remove this scourge from our land.
Men cannot be allowed to abuse women with impunity! Women’s lives matter, their complaints must be taken seriously by the authorities, and they deserve to get proper treatment under the law!
Ms. Nagamootoo, you can be part of the solution once again. We demand and expect more from you. Please re-commit yourself to removing abusers like Charles Goodluck from our society for good, so that they cannot continue to hurt and maim women willy nilly. And if you say that you were not aware of his record, well, advocating for a computerized information database within the police and judicial system should become part of you and your colleagues’ work.
Sherlina Nageer

Latest News

Magistrate’s weak stance on domestic violence case disappoints

Related

Similar Articles

The Glenn Lall Show | January, 27th, 2025

Follow on Tik Tok @Glennlall

THE BLUNT OF THE DAY

Sports

Savory (95), Anderson (87) century stand bails Harpy Eagles out of...

Slingerz FC assembles powerhouse squad for GFF...

Project “Cricket Gear for young and promising...

Everest CC extends best wishes to Looknauth on...

Sir Clyde Walcott: the captain who led British...

Berbice Cricket Board names squad for senior...

Features/Columnists

Show us the numbers!

OAS Secretary General Election and renewed OAS Consensus

Drill, baby, drill – brick walls and politics

Publisher’s Note

Weekend Cartoon

Bridge Watch

Demerara Harbour Bridge

> Berbice Bridge […]

Magistrate’s weak stance on domestic violence case disappoints

Share this:

Related

Similar Articles

The Glenn Lall Show | January, 27th, 2025

Follow on Tik Tok @Glennlall

THE BLUNT OF THE DAY

Sports

Features/Columnists

Publisher’s Note

Weekend Cartoon

Bridge Watch

Demerara Harbour Bridge

> Berbice Bridge […]